Lower premiums are a key factor in switching decisions among UK pet insurance customers, according to GlobalData’s research. Meanwhile, new findings from Defaqto show that pet insurance prices have fallen over the past year, potentially creating further opportunities for insurers to attract price-sensitive customers.

According to GlobalData’s 2025 UK Insurance Consumer Survey, over 50% of both cat and dog insurance switchers cited a lower premium offered by their new insurer as a reason for changing provider. This highlights the importance of competitive pricing in customers’ decisions, particularly as insurers seek to attract and retain policyholders.

Defaqto’s latest Pet Insurance Pricing Index, which tracks the average of the five most competitive quotes in the market, found that average top five lifetime premiums fell by 14% over the past 12 months, including a 6.1% reduction in Q3 2026. However, reductions varied by coverage level: policies offering at least £1,000 in veterinary fee cover recorded a 14% decline, compared with 7% for those offering at least £5,000. This suggests insurers are competing more aggressively on lower-cover products, while price cuts on more comprehensive policies have been more modest.

Lifetime premiums also fell further for dogs than for cats, declining by 15% and 12%, respectively. Beyond lifetime cover, maximum benefit and time-limited policies recorded much smaller annual reductions of 4% and 1%, respectively. Defaqto attributes this to less intense competition in these segments, where fewer brands offer cover.

For pet insurers, falling premiums could encourage more shopping around and switching, particularly among price-motivated customers. However, this effect depends on the gap between new business and renewal pricing. If quotes for new customers fall faster than renewal premiums, existing policyholders have a stronger incentive to switch. If renewal prices fall in line, that incentive weakens. This creates opportunities to win new policyholders through competitive quotes, but it also increases pressure to keep renewal pricing competitive and retain existing customers. Providers must also ensure that lower premiums do not come at the expense of adequate protection—particularly where cheaper policies carry lower veterinary fee limits. Clearly communicating coverage differences, exclusions, and excesses will help customers make informed decisions and support long-term retention.